After spending one year in the Philadelphia Phillies minor league system, the Mets selected right handed pitcher Darrell Sutherland off waivers prior to the 1964 season. After starting the 1964 season in the minors, Sutherland made his Major League debut with the Mets on June 28th against the Milwaukee Brewers. He started the game and lasted just 1/3 of an inning allowing three hits and five earned runs. He would appear in ten games for the Mets, four as a starter, before being shipped back to the minors in August. For the season, he went 0-3 with 7.76 ERA in 26 2/3 innings.
Sutherland once again started the 1965 season in the minors. He returned to the Mets on August 8th and pitched remarkably well for the remainder of the season. In 18 appearances, two as a starter, he won 3 and lost 1 while posting a 2.81 ERA in 48 innings. His first career win came on August 10th against the Houston Astros when he pitched four innings of relief without allowing a hit in a game the Mets would win 1-0.
In 1966, he split time between the majors and the minors appearing in 31 games for the Mets all out of the bullpen. He posted a 2-0 record but his ERA 4.87 in 44 1/3 innings.
1966 would be his last season with the Mets, he spent the entire 1967 season in the minors with the Williamsport Mets, their double A affiliate, where he posted a 6-3 record with 4.11 ERA. From there he moved on to the Cleveland Indians organization.
In 59 games for the Mets Sutherland posted a 5-4 record with 4.69 ERA in a 119 innings. Each of his 5 victories came in relief while each of his 4 losses came as a starter.
While with the Mets Sutherland wore number 47 in 1964, number 43 in 1965 and number 46 in 1966.
Darrel Sutherland also played for the Cleveland Indians in 1968.